Justia Civil Rights Opinion Summaries

by
A child with Down syndrome, Annie, experienced significant medical complications early in life but was later able to walk and talk. When she turned three, her mother sought special education services for her from the local school district. The district intended to conduct an initial evaluation to determine eligibility for services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), which would include both informal and formal cognitive assessments. Annie’s mother objected to certain formal cognitive tests, believing they were inappropriate, and only consented to the informal assessment. The district interpreted this as insufficient consent and informed the parents that a restricted consent form would not allow them to proceed with the evaluation.The parents requested an administrative due-process hearing, seeking an order to compel the district to evaluate Annie with only their preferred tests. The hearing officer concluded that the district’s proposed evaluation was appropriate and that the parents had not met their burden to show the formal tests were invalid or inappropriate. The officer also found that the district had made reasonable efforts to obtain consent and that withholding consent prevented the district from fulfilling its obligations under IDEA.The parents then filed suit in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas, alleging violations of IDEA and the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). The district court granted summary judgment in favor of the school district on both claims. On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit affirmed the district court’s ruling as to the IDEA claim, holding that partial parental consent is insufficient to trigger the district’s obligations and that the district’s proposed evaluation complied with IDEA. However, the Fifth Circuit reversed the summary judgment on the ADA claim, holding the district court erred in its interpretation of the ADA’s requirements and remanded the ADA claim for further proceedings. View "M. v. Aledo" on Justia Law

by
After receiving information from confidential sources and conducting independent surveillance, a St. Louis police detective obtained a no-knock search warrant for a residence suspected of being involved in drug and firearms activity. During the execution of the warrant by a SWAT team, officers announced themselves as they breached the door. The resident, Don Clark, fired a shot at the officers, missing them, and was then fatally shot by Officer Manasco, who believed Clark posed an immediate threat. The search yielded firearms and various drugs. Clark’s children brought claims against the officers and the City of St. Louis, alleging violations of the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments and state law.The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri dismissed several claims and defendants, leaving only certain claims against Detective Strode, Officer Manasco, and the City. The district court granted summary judgment to all remaining defendants, finding no genuine dispute of material fact regarding the lawfulness of the search, the application for the no-knock warrant, the use of the SWAT team, the use of deadly force, and the City’s liability. The court also held Strode was entitled to official immunity on the wrongful death claim.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment. The appellate court held that the plaintiffs failed to show that the warrant affidavit contained deliberately or recklessly false statements, that the no-knock entry and SWAT deployment violated clearly established law, or that excessive force was used, given the circumstances. It further found no basis for municipal liability in the absence of an underlying constitutional violation and concluded that official immunity barred the wrongful death claim under Missouri law. Thus, the summary judgment for all defendants was affirmed. View "Clark v. City of St. Louis" on Justia Law

by
Gerald C. Prophete, a resident at a homeless shelter operated by the Department of Homeless Services (DHS), alleged that he was assaulted by shelter staff, specifically DHS officers, after an incident involving the shelter’s identification card scanner. Prophete claimed he was pepper-sprayed and handcuffed without justification, while the officers testified that Prophete had been disruptive, including spitting on a shelter employee and acting aggressively, which led to their use of force. Prophete was issued summonses for disorderly conduct and harassment, which were ultimately dismissed.In the United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York, Prophete sought to impeach the credibility of Defendant-Appellee Haydee Acevedo-Smith by cross-examining her about disciplinary reports from unrelated incidents—where she allegedly made inaccurate statements and used excessive force—under Federal Rule of Evidence 608(b). The district court denied this request, finding the reports did not constitute clear adverse credibility findings and, alternatively, that allowing such questioning would be unduly prejudicial and confusing under Rule 403. A jury verdict was returned in favor of the defendants on all claims, and the district court entered judgment accordingly.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reviewed whether the district court erred in precluding cross-examination on the disciplinary reports. The appellate court held that, even assuming the district court’s Rule 608(b) analysis was erroneous, it did not abuse its discretion in excluding the evidence under Rule 403 due to the risk of unfair prejudice and jury confusion. Therefore, the Second Circuit affirmed the judgment of the district court. View "Prophete v. Acevedo-Smith" on Justia Law

by
A man was stopped by law enforcement in Marion County, West Virginia, while driving a Jeep with an inoperable brake light and a mismatched license plate. During the stop, he appeared nervous, admitted to not having a valid license, and refused consent to search the vehicle. A drug-sniffing dog alerted to the presence of narcotics. The subsequent search revealed a loaded firearm in the center console, a substantial quantity of methamphetamine and fentanyl, drug trafficking paraphernalia, and $1,863 in cash on the driver. The vehicle had recently been purchased by the man from an acquaintance, but the title was still in the seller’s name. Both the driver and his passenger were arrested.After indictment on eight counts, a jury in the Circuit Court of Marion County found the man guilty of six felony offenses, including conspiracy and possession with intent to deliver controlled substances, and possession of a firearm by a prohibited person. The jury acquitted him of one firearm-related offense and one drug charge was dismissed. Following the convictions, the State filed a recidivist information based on two prior felony convictions—strangulation and fleeing in a vehicle with reckless indifference. At a recidivist trial, the jury found the defendant had committed the prior felonies. The circuit court imposed several concurrent sentences on the substantive offenses and a life sentence with parole eligibility, pursuant to the recidivist statute, for possession of a firearm by a prohibited person.On appeal to the Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia, the defendant challenged the sufficiency of the evidence and the constitutionality of his life recidivist sentence. The court held that the evidence, when viewed most favorably to the prosecution, was sufficient for a rational jury to convict on all counts. Additionally, the court found that the triggering and predicate felonies met the statutory and constitutional requirements for a life recidivist sentence. The sentencing order was affirmed. View "State v. Valentine" on Justia Law

by
Jonathan López-Díaz pleaded guilty in 2014 to bank robbery and illegal possession of a firearm, serving ninety-three months in prison. After release, he began supervised release but repeatedly violated its conditions, including multiple positive drug tests for cocaine and marijuana and admitted drug use. The United States Probation Office reported additional violations, such as failing to follow instructions, not reporting law enforcement contacts, and missing treatment appointments. After these repeated violations, the district court revoked his supervised release twice, ultimately sentencing him to twelve months’ imprisonment with no further supervised release following his second revocation.The United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico originally handled López’s supervised release and revocation proceedings. After López’s second revocation, his counsel argued at the revocation hearing that his violations should be classified as Grade C rather than Grade B under the Sentencing Guidelines, which would result in a lower advisory sentencing range. Counsel also argued for leniency and additional supervision with rehabilitative conditions rather than incarceration. The government contended that López’s conduct constituted a Grade B violation, given his admissions and repeated positive drug tests, and requested imprisonment without further supervised release.The United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit reviewed López’s appeal. Applying abuse-of-discretion review, the court held that the district court correctly classified López’s violation as a Grade B violation based on his admissions and corroborating evidence. The First Circuit further found the district court’s sentencing rationale did not improperly rely on retributive factors barred by Esteras v. United States, and that the imposed sentence was both procedurally and substantively reasonable. The court affirmed López’s twelve-month sentence with no term of supervision to follow. View "US v. Lopez-Diaz" on Justia Law

by
Several individuals required to register as sex offenders under Michigan’s Sex Offenders Registration Act (“SORA 2021”) challenged the statute’s constitutionality after its 2021 amendment. Most plaintiffs had committed their offenses before 2011 and had their registration terms retroactively extended, often to lifetime registration, without individualized risk assessments. SORA 2021 retained offense-based tier assignments and many reporting and public notification requirements, although it removed some prior features such as student safety zones and tier designations from public display.The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan certified a class and subclasses, and addressed several constitutional challenges. The district court granted summary judgment to the plaintiffs on their ex post facto claims regarding retroactive application, and on procedural due process claims for individuals with non-Michigan convictions, finding that Michigan State Police’s process lacked sufficient procedural protections. It rejected plaintiffs’ substantive due process and equal protection challenges to offense-based tiers and their equal protection challenge to petitioning restrictions, concluding SORA 2021 was rationally related to recidivism reduction. The court also rejected void-for-vagueness claims concerning certain reporting requirements.On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reviewed the district court’s judgment de novo. The court vacated and remanded the ex post facto claims and retroactive plea agreement claim for the district court to determine whether they were mooted by a recent Michigan Supreme Court decision holding SORA 2021’s retroactive application unconstitutional. The Sixth Circuit affirmed the district court’s rejection of substantive due process and equal protection challenges to offense-based tiers and petitioning restrictions, holding these provisions were rationally related to legitimate state interests. It also affirmed the district court’s finding that Michigan’s process for registering individuals with non-Michigan convictions violated procedural due process rights, and upheld the dismissal of void-for-vagueness claims regarding education, employment, and vehicle reporting. The judgment was affirmed in part, vacated in part, and remanded for further proceedings. View "Doe v. Whitmer" on Justia Law

by
A prisoner serving life imprisonment following a death sentence challenged the conditions of his long-term solitary confinement in a high-security Connecticut facility. After the death penalty was abolished in Connecticut, the inmate’s sentence was changed to life without parole, but he remained in solitary confinement under conditions mandated by a state statute (section 18-10b). He argued that these conditions violated his rights under the Eighth Amendment and the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.Previously, the United States District Court for the District of Connecticut denied the prison officials’ motion for judgment as a matter of law based on qualified immunity and granted the prisoner’s motion for a new trial. The District Court had also divided the due process claim into two periods: before and after 2017, and a jury found the officials liable only for the period after 2017. The court ordered a new trial on the Eighth Amendment claim, ruling that the jury’s verdict was against the weight of the evidence, and denied judgment as a matter of law for the officials on both the Eighth Amendment and due process claims.The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit reviewed the case. It determined it lacked jurisdiction to review the denial of qualified immunity for the Eighth Amendment claim, as unresolved factual disputes remained. However, the court found it had jurisdiction over the denial of qualified immunity on the post-2017 due process claim because the relevant facts were undisputed. The court held that the prison officials did not violate clearly established law regarding the due process claim and were therefore entitled to qualified immunity for that period. The appeal was dismissed in part, the district court’s order was reversed in part, and the case was remanded for further proceedings. View "Reynolds v. Quiros" on Justia Law

by
Ronald L. Green, a revenue agent employed by the Internal Revenue Service in Las Vegas, was indefinitely suspended in August 2006 on suspicion of filing fraudulent tax returns. Shortly before the suspension took effect, he applied for immediate disability retirement, citing medical conditions and workplace stress. After his suspension, he initiated arbitration to challenge the agency’s action and alleged discrimination through an EEO complaint. The Office of Personnel Management approved his retirement in January 2007. In March 2007, an arbitrator reversed his suspension but denied his discrimination claims. The agency retroactively dated his retirement to his last day of pay and removed references to other adverse actions from his record.Mr. Green’s subsequent legal efforts included appeals to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and district court, both of which ruled against him, with the Ninth Circuit affirming. In May 2023, he appealed to the Merit Systems Protection Board, asserting that his 2006 retirement was involuntary due to agency actions and discrimination. The administrative judge dismissed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction, finding that Mr. Green failed to nonfrivolously allege involuntariness. The decision became the Board’s final determination.The United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit reviewed Mr. Green’s petition. It first determined jurisdiction, concluding that Mr. Green’s explicit waiver of discrimination claims allowed the court to review the non-discrimination aspects. The court found that Mr. Green had forfeited arguments about agency failure to restore his employment after arbitration because these were not properly raised before the Board. On the remaining issue, the court held that Mr. Green failed to nonfrivolously allege that his retirement was involuntary, either through coercion or misinformation, and affirmed the Board’s decision. View "Green v. Merit Systems Protection Board" on Justia Law

by
Kelly was suspected of illegal drug activity after Detective Jonathan Smith observed a drug sale involving a black male who left the scene in a red vehicle with a white female passenger. Shortly after, Deputy Cody Jett received an anonymous tip indicating Heather McDonald would arrive in a red Hyundai at a McDonald’s restaurant, accompanied by a black male driver, and that both individuals possessed heroin and were dealing drugs. Deputy Jett verified an arrest warrant for McDonald. At the restaurant, Jett observed a vehicle matching the tip, McDonald, and a black male later identified as Kelly. After Kelly and McDonald responded to Jett’s instructions, McDonald attempted to flee and was apprehended, while Kelly was detained and eventually admitted there were drugs in the vehicle. Officers subsequently obtained a search warrant, found additional evidence, and arrested Kelly for driving with a suspended license and several drug offenses.The United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida initially denied the officers’ motion to dismiss under Heck v. Humphrey, finding it could not conclude at that stage that Kelly’s Fourth Amendment claims were barred. Later, upon motions for summary judgment, the district court granted summary judgment in favor of the officers, holding that Heck barred Kelly’s suit because success would imply the invalidity of his convictions. The district court did not address qualified immunity.The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit reviewed the case de novo and declined to base its decision on Heck. Instead, the appellate court found that both Deputy Jett and Detective Smith were entitled to qualified immunity because there was probable cause to detain Kelly, given the corroborated anonymous tip and observed circumstances. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed the summary judgment in favor of the officers. View "Kelly v. Jett" on Justia Law

by
A Sedona resident, who has obsessive-compulsive disorder, often sleeps in her car because her disability prevents her from entering her apartment. The City of Sedona has a criminal ordinance prohibiting sleeping in a vehicle on public or private property. The resident was twice warned by police for sleeping in her car and requested reasonable accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) to exempt her from enforcement of this ordinance. The city denied her requests, and her landlord threatened not to renew her lease if she continued sleeping in her car. She alleges that the city’s actions caused her emotional distress and loss of income, and she continues to sleep in her car several times a week.The United States District Court for the District of Arizona dismissed her claims for lack of standing, finding that the prior police warnings were insufficient to support a specific threat of prosecution and that she failed to allege a history of enforcement against similarly situated individuals. The district court addressed only her standing to seek injunctive relief, despite her claims for damages as well. Her requests to amend her complaint were denied, and she appealed.The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed in part and reversed in part the district court’s dismissal. The Ninth Circuit held that she had Article III standing to bring an ADA claim for both damages and injunctive relief, based on the city’s denial of her request for accommodation and a credible threat of future enforcement. The court further held that Title II of the ADA applies to requests for reasonable accommodation to comply with municipal criminal ordinances. The ADA claim was remanded for further proceedings, allowing her to amend her complaint, while the dismissal of her Eighth Amendment claim was affirmed. View "BERAM V. CITY OF SEDONA" on Justia Law